The Autumn Series matches serve as a thrilling showcase of the intense rivalry between the Southern Hemisphere teams—South Africa, New Zealand, Australia, Argentina, and Fiji—and their Northern Hemisphere counterparts—England, France, Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and Italy.
The debate over which region truly reigns supreme—North or South—is one that captivates audiences and avid fans alike. As a staunch South African, my unwavering loyalty lies firmly with the South. The intensity of their matches and their extraordinary style of play embody everything I cherish about rugby.
When we analyze Rugby World Cups, the facts speak for themselves: the South is overwhelmingly dominant, securing an incredible 9 out of the last ten titles:
- South Africa: 4 titles
- New Zealand: 3 titles
- Australia: 2 titles
- England: 1 title
While the North has shown commendable growth, particularly through Ireland's recent triumphs and France's fierce competitiveness, it is the South that undoubtedly sets the gold standard.
The 2023 World Cup in France solidified this dominance, as South Africa triumphed over New Zealand in the final, clinching their fourth title. Furthermore, the current results from the Autumn Series Games underscore Southern supremacy:
**Week 1 - 2 November**
- England 22 - 24 New Zealand
- Scotland 57 - 17 Fiji
**Week 2 - 9 November**
- Ireland 13 - 23 New Zealand
- England 37 - 42 Australia
- Italy 18 - 50 Argentina
- Wales 19 - 24 Fiji
- Scotland 15 - 32 South Africa
**Week 3 - 16 November**
- Ireland 22 - 19 Argentina
- England 20 - 29 South Africa
- France 30 - 29 New Zealand
- Wales 20 - 52 Australia
With a tally of eight wins for the South against only three for the North, it’s clear that the upcoming week holds immense potential for electrifying matchups—can the North finally claim a victory against the South?
The South's recent successes and consistent results against their Northern rivals leave no room for doubt regarding the resurgence of Southern prowess in rugby.
What accounts for the South's excellence?
In South Africa and New Zealand, rugby is more than just a game; it is a cornerstone of national identity. Players like Siya Kolisi, Dan Carter, Richie McCaw, Jonah Lomu, Eben Etzebeth, and Pieter-Steph Du Toit are celebrated as national icons. Young athletes aspire to wear the Green and Gold or the All Black jersey, driven by a fervor for rugby that far surpasses the enthusiasm found in the North, where other sports such as football and Gaelic games often overshadow rugby.
Rassie on South Africa
Many players from the South emerge from challenging backgrounds, fostering an unparalleled tenacity, determination, and passion that resonates powerfully on the field. This fierce motivation consistently drives them to make significant impacts on their countries and communities.
Rugby in Fji
Ashwin Williamse Story
While both hemispheres share stylistic similarities—South Africa, Argentina, and England leaning towards a more physical approach, and Australia, New Zealand, France, and Fiji favoring an expansive game—the South consistently elevates the sport with unmatched intensity and speed. Conversely, the North tends to rely more on a territorial strategy.
Some might suggest that weather conditions influence these playing styles, citing the drier pitches in the South versus the wetter conditions in the North. However, a closer examination reveals that New Zealand ranks 45th in rainfall, while the UK ranks 72nd, proving that weather is not a pivotal factor in this debate.
Critical elements contribute to the South's sustained success, particularly in skill development. Young players in New Zealand, Australia, and Fiji grow up playing touch rugby or rippa which cultivates essential skills—catching, passing, spatial awareness, communication, game sense, and agility—paramount for success on the field.
Rippa Rugby
Touch Rugby - Richie Mounga
Let’s not forget the Northern Hemisphere, which boasts exceptional talent like Marcus Smith, Johnny Sexton, Finn Russell, and Antoine Dupont—undeniably among the world’s best players.
We are also witnessing a significant trend of players and coaches from the South moving to the North for opportunities that provide financial stability and invaluable experiences. This movement signals that clubs and nations in the North are beginning to recognize the progressive mindset of the South’s players and coaches.
Consider the impact of Joe Schmidt, whose innovative leadership with Ireland laid the groundwork for their recent successes, or Michael Cheika’s transformative role at Leicester Tigers after his remarkable achievements with Leinster.
And let’s not overlook Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus, whose tenure at Munster yielded immense success. His innovative strategies—from the bomb squad to the traffic light system—have sparked considerable discussion. His calculated risks and forward-thinking mindset have propelled South Africa to the summit of international rugby, where they currently stand as World Number 1.
While Ireland and France are undoubtedly on a commendable development path with their evolving playing styles, the question remains: are teams in the North still anchored to outdated traditions?
Multiple factors at play highlight the South's success in rugby, and it's hard to pinpoint each one, but the North having success at the U20 World Cup over the last fours could be the catalyst for what's to come in the future
What are your thoughts?
Comments